Difference between revisions of "Wikipedia:Israeli targeted killings"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{WpPage | {{WpPage | ||
|WsLink0=Israeli targeted killings | |WsLink0=Israeli targeted killings | ||
| − | |WpIntro=The multiple Wikipedia pages on "assassinations | + | |WpIntro=The multiple Wikipedia pages on "targetted killings" (assassinations) are wordy treatments showing great selectivity and bias. |
| − | + | Wikispooks tries to avoid duplicating Wikipedia treatment of the subject, but in this case the only directly equivalent article is missing most of what would belong in an article written to their published standards (being the same standards as Wikispooks aspires to meet). | |
| − | + | There is no listing of these killings, Israel or otherwise, anywhere in the Wikipedia, which is very different from the situation of, say, Russian journalists. See [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_journalists_killed_in_Russia#Deaths_and_trials.2C_statistics here] for a table of all such deaths, part of a detailed discussion accompanied by lists (including "all violent, premature and unexplained" deaths of "reporters, editors, cameramen, photographers"). | |
| − | |||
| − | |||
|WpURL=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/{{PAGENAMEE}} | |WpURL=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/{{PAGENAMEE}} | ||
|Stub=No | |Stub=No | ||
|ExLink1=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_the_Israeli_government | |ExLink1=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_the_Israeli_government | ||
| − | |ExLink1Name=Wikipedia's "Criticism of Israel" | + | |ExLink1Name=Wikipedia's "Criticism of Israel" |
| − | |ExLink1Desc=This very large Wikipedia article (150,000 bytes) has a brief passage suggesting that Israel is under considerable criticism for assassinations but points the reader to heavily distorted [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israeli_targeted_killings "Israeli targeted killings"] article | + | |ExLink1Desc=This very large Wikipedia article (150,000 bytes) has a brief passage suggesting that Israel is under considerable criticism for assassinations but points the reader to the heavily distorted [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israeli_targeted_killings "Israeli targeted killings"] equivalent article. Persistent reference is made to antisemitism as a major factor. |
|ExLink2=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israeli_targeted_killings | |ExLink2=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israeli_targeted_killings | ||
|ExLink2Name=Wikipedia's "Israeli targeted killings" | |ExLink2Name=Wikipedia's "Israeli targeted killings" | ||
| Line 18: | Line 16: | ||
|ExLink3=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination | |ExLink3=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination | ||
|ExLink3Name=Wikipedia's "Assassination" | |ExLink3Name=Wikipedia's "Assassination" | ||
| − | |ExLink3Desc=This large Wikipedia article (55,000 bytes) obscures with statements such as "many allege that ... covert and illegal training of assassins continues today, with Russia, Israel, the U.S., Argentina, Paraguay, Chile, and other nations accused" and "Israel has assassinated Hamas and Hezbollah leaders". Two Israeli political victims are mentioned, the less significant Tourist Minister (victim of Palestinians) getting much more coverage than the Prime Minister. | + | |ExLink3Desc=This large Wikipedia article (55,000 bytes) obscures with statements such as "many allege that ... covert and illegal training of assassins continues today, with Russia, Israel, the U.S., Argentina, Paraguay, Chile, and other nations accused" and "Israel has assassinated Hamas and Hezbollah leaders". Two Israeli political victims are mentioned, the less significant Tourist Minister (victim of Palestinians) getting much more coverage than the Prime Minister. |
|ExLink4=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Targeted_killing | |ExLink4=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Targeted_killing | ||
|ExLink4Name=Wikipedia's "Targeted killing" | |ExLink4Name=Wikipedia's "Targeted killing" | ||
| − | |ExLink4Desc=This Wikipedia article (23,000 bytes) concentrates on US drone killings under Obama and begins with a section "Legal justification". | + | |ExLink4Desc=This Wikipedia article (23,000 bytes) concentrates on US drone killings under Obama and begins with a section "Legal justification". It has some mention of Israeli killings and some implied criticism, but also quotes such as "there are strong reasons to believe that the Israeli policy of targeted killing is not the same as assassination". |
}} | }} | ||
Revision as of 12:56, 8 June 2012
 Israeli targeted killings
|
 Israeli targeted killings
|
| The multiple Wikipedia pages on "targetted killings" (assassinations) are wordy treatments showing great selectivity and bias.
Wikispooks tries to avoid duplicating Wikipedia treatment of the subject, but in this case the only directly equivalent article is missing most of what would belong in an article written to their published standards (being the same standards as Wikispooks aspires to meet). There is no listing of these killings, Israel or otherwise, anywhere in the Wikipedia, which is very different from the situation of, say, Russian journalists. See here for a table of all such deaths, part of a detailed discussion accompanied by lists (including "all violent, premature and unexplained" deaths of "reporters, editors, cameramen, photographers"). |
Related Wikispooks Pages
External Links
- Wikipedia's "Criticism of Israel" - This very large Wikipedia article (150,000 bytes) has a brief passage suggesting that Israel is under considerable criticism for assassinations but points the reader to the heavily distorted "Israeli targeted killings" equivalent article. Persistent reference is made to antisemitism as a major factor.
- Wikipedia's "Israeli targeted killings" - This Wikipedia article (30,000 bytes) is heavily loaded in favour of the Israeli narrative. It claims a 1:30 civilian/target casualty rate in 2008 which it quotes Alan Dershowitz as calling "the lowest civilian to combatant casualty ratio in history in the setting of combating terrorism".
- Wikipedia's "Assassination" - This large Wikipedia article (55,000 bytes) obscures with statements such as "many allege that ... covert and illegal training of assassins continues today, with Russia, Israel, the U.S., Argentina, Paraguay, Chile, and other nations accused" and "Israel has assassinated Hamas and Hezbollah leaders". Two Israeli political victims are mentioned, the less significant Tourist Minister (victim of Palestinians) getting much more coverage than the Prime Minister.
- Wikipedia's "Targeted killing" - This Wikipedia article (23,000 bytes) concentrates on US drone killings under Obama and begins with a section "Legal justification". It has some mention of Israeli killings and some implied criticism, but also quotes such as "there are strong reasons to believe that the Israeli policy of targeted killing is not the same as assassination".
