Difference between revisions of "Dr Rola"
m (→Public right to know: add sub heading) |
m (→BBC Panorama Footage: edits) |
||
| Line 19: | Line 19: | ||
===BBC Panorama Footage=== | ===BBC Panorama Footage=== | ||
| − | In separate BBC Panorama footage which included video described as 'unverified' but shown nonetheless, a female introduced as ''"An English Doctor"'' was filmed in Aleppo in the claimed aftermath of the alleged attack. In a related Daily Telegraph article she was again described as an 'English Doctor working at a London Hospital' and volunteering for relief work in Syria through 'Hand-in-Hand-for-Syria' <ref>[http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/middleeast/syria/10276910/Syria-BBC-Panorama-films-napalm-attack-on-school.html Syria: BBC Panorama films 'napalm' attack on school] - Telegraph Friday 30 August 2013</ref>. The impression conveyed in the Newsnight piece | + | In separate BBC Panorama footage which included video described as 'unverified' but shown nonetheless, a female introduced as ''"An English Doctor"'' was filmed in Aleppo in the claimed aftermath of the alleged attack. In a related Daily Telegraph article she was again described as an 'English Doctor working at a London Hospital' and volunteering for relief work in Syria through 'Hand-in-Hand-for-Syria' <ref>[http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/middleeast/syria/10276910/Syria-BBC-Panorama-films-napalm-attack-on-school.html Syria: BBC Panorama films 'napalm' attack on school] - Telegraph Friday 30 August 2013</ref>. Towards the end of the video she opined in an impeccably Estuary English accent '''''"The whole world has failed our nation"''''' - so, is she Syrian or English? |
| + | |||
| + | Although not explicitly stated, the strong impression conveyed in the Newsnight piece is that these two women are one and the same person, but the video clearly shows that they are ''different'' people. So who is she? because '''she is certainly NOT the Newsnight Dr Rola.''' | ||
===Details of claimed role=== | ===Details of claimed role=== | ||
Revision as of 15:56, 2 September 2013
 |
{{{Add text here}}} |
Contents
Who is Dr Rola?
Dr Rola Hallem MBBS, BSc, FRCA
From her 'role of honour' entry on the ATFAL website:
Rola is a doctor in anaesthesia and intensive care, with a passion for education, child and global health.
Drawing on her previous charitable work in sub-Saharan Africa, Rola has been working since the beginning of the Syria crisis on delivery of aid to Syria, raising awareness and advocacy.
Dr Rola Alkurdi FRCA
This page suggests Dr Rola Alkurdi, "Education Fellow + Registrar in Anaesthesia"[1].
Appearances
BBC Newsnight on 30 August 2013
Introduced to BBC Newsnight viewers as "A British Doctor just back from volunteering in Syria who wants to be called 'Dr Rola'" an attractive thirty-something lady described her experience of an alleged napalm attack in Aleppo, Syria as "...one of the most horrific few hours of my life". Speaking in an educated English - with just a trace of East Midlands - accent, she gave a bravura, restrained-emotional performance describing the horrors she had witnessed and advocating Western military intervention in support of Syrian anti-government forces. It is not too much of a stretch to say that, had her interview been broadcast before the UK House of Commons vote which had declined military action a few hours earlier, the outcome may well have been different. Her performance was that persuasive. Her access to funding for her cause is clearly no problem because, during the interview she pointedly offered to host a 7 day visit by Ed Milliband and his family to Aleppo "... to see for himself and at my expense" [2]
BBC Panorama Footage
In separate BBC Panorama footage which included video described as 'unverified' but shown nonetheless, a female introduced as "An English Doctor" was filmed in Aleppo in the claimed aftermath of the alleged attack. In a related Daily Telegraph article she was again described as an 'English Doctor working at a London Hospital' and volunteering for relief work in Syria through 'Hand-in-Hand-for-Syria' [3]. Towards the end of the video she opined in an impeccably Estuary English accent "The whole world has failed our nation" - so, is she Syrian or English?
Although not explicitly stated, the strong impression conveyed in the Newsnight piece is that these two women are one and the same person, but the video clearly shows that they are different people. So who is she? because she is certainly NOT the Newsnight Dr Rola.
Details of claimed role
It is claimed Dr Rola was volunteering through a UK registered charity 'Hand-in-Hand-for-Syria' [4]. The charity was incorporated on 13 February 2012. [5] and is yet [as at 31 August 2013] to file any accounting information. Its web site was set up on a shared hosting server in the Netherlands on 1 March 2012. [6]
The disconnect between an implied Hippocratic-oath-defined, altruistic concern for the innocent victims of military bombardment on the one hand, and simultaneous advocacy for more such bombardment on the other, made for compelling but truly bizarre television. One cannot help but question whether Dr Rola does not have a hidden agenda.
The Nurse Nayirah affair
To those who remember the run-up to the first Iraq war in 1990, it carried disturbing echoes of the Nurse Nayirah episode, in which the daughter of the Kuwaiti ambassador to the US, anonymously and fraudulently claimed that she had witnessed Iraqi troops "throwing new-born babies from incubators and leaving them to die on the cold floor". She had been coached by the US PR firm Hill & Knowlton, retained by the Kuwait government to make the case for war, and her father sat behind her as she delivered her testimony (as simply a volunteer 'student nurse' who, for security reasons, wished to remain anonymous) before the US Congress.
Public right to know
You do not volunteer to appear on the flag-ship BBC Politics TV program advocating for a military bombing campaign with any realistic expectation - let alone right - to remain anonymous.
The use of medical, charitable and otherwise altruistic credentials as qualifications to advocate for military intervention of ANY kind - let alone the sort of cowardly stand-off high-tech carnage Dr Rola was effectively shilling for on BBC Newsnight is, by any civilised standard, deeply offensive behaviour.
In the fraught circumstances of a rising drum-beat crescendo for military intervention in Syria, the public has an absolute right to know exactly who Dr Rola is and what her connection are.
Request for information
Please send any relevant information to:
- admin[at]wikispooks.org - PGP public key or
- use the anonymous upload/contact form
- Twitter hash-tag #WhoIsDrRola
Anti-Israeli Torture Letter
Dr Rola Alkurdi was one of 725 doctors who signed a 2009 open letter demanding the dismissal of newly-appointed WMA president, Dr Yoram Blachar because of Israeli doctors complicity in the torture of Palestinians [7]
References
- ↑ UCL Staff page
- ↑ Syria crisis: Doctor criticises Miliband over MPs' vote - BBC News 31 August 2013
- ↑ Syria: BBC Panorama films 'napalm' attack on school - Telegraph Friday 30 August 2013
- ↑ Hand in Hand for Syria - Home page
- ↑ Charity Commission - Statutory information on 'Hand-in-Hand-for-Syria' at 31 August 2013
- ↑ []
- ↑ Torture-row doctors stick the knife in
